• Home
  • OPINION
  • At Last, Men Have a Day to Speak Up-By Kumar Bahukhandi

At Last, Men Have a Day to Speak Up-By Kumar Bahukhandi

0Shares
Image

Two friends talk over chai in an illustration for At Last, Men Have a Day to Speak Up, a Men’s Day column about what it takes to get past “I’m fine.”:Illustration:primelookindia.com

On International Men’s Day, a man attempts the most difficult sentence in his vocabulary: “Actually, I could use some help.”

In a piece I wrote for International Women’s Day, I Am Doing Nothing Today, I began by wondering why my inbox was full of press invitations and nobody had invited me for a beer. I even reminded my fellow men that we had a day of our own on 19 November. The joke eventually caught up with the narrator. He had plenty to say about the way women were treated, and his final contribution to the matter was to do absolutely nothing.

This year, I thought I might improve on that performance. At least we men have a day on which we can speak up. The difficulty is that when someone finally asks us how we are, we say, “Fine.”

We say it with astonishing conviction. The car is making a noise, the bank has sent a message that begins with Dear Valued Customer, and we have been awake since three in the morning doing calculations that would embarrass a chartered accountant. But how are we?

“Fine. You?”

The “you” is important. It gets the conversation safely away from us.

The man who can talk for forty minutes

I know men who can explain, in considerable detail, why India lost a match they watched from a sofa. They can identify the precise over in which the captain lost his nerve. Ask one of them how he has been since his father died and he will study his tea for a moment and say, “Keeping busy.”

I recognise the technique. I teach journalism. I tell my students that when somebody gives them a rehearsed answer, they should ask a follow-up. Naturally, when somebody asks me a follow-up, I remember an urgent phone call I have to make.

There is also the matter of asking for help. A man can spend a whole Sunday repairing something he has already made worse because calling someone on Saturday would have involved admitting he didn’t know what he was doing. By Sunday evening, three people are holding a torch, somebody has gone out to buy a new part, and he is explaining to the family that the original problem was actually quite simple.

I see no reason to pretend I am above any of this. I have asked for directions while insisting I knew exactly where I was going. The man I asked was kind enough to let me finish.

One more question over tea

I still think about the ending of that Women’s Day piece. The man who called himself decent had found a comfortable place to stand while other people dealt with the consequences of his silence. Silence can be comfortable that way. It can also be lonely. I have sat across from friends who were plainly having a difficult time and let “keeping busy” pass because I knew the next question might make both of us uncomfortable.

Sometimes the opening is small. A grown son says to his father, “I wish we talked more,” and his father asks whether he has eaten. In my experience, the father may bring out two plates and sit down. The son can try again while they eat.

So here is my modest ambition for Men’s Day. The next time a friend tells me he is fine and I have reason to wonder, I’ll stay for another cup of tea and ask him how he has been sleeping. If he asks me the same question, I’ll try to answer it.

Of course, I may still start with “Fine.” Old habits deserve a little notice. But if you’re the one asking, give me a minute. I’ve been preparing the second sentence for years.